Figure: Housing affordability changes across urban-rural and income spectrums show affordability worsening most in the lower-income urban center of Columbus.
Figure 1, titled "2019 to 2024 HPI Growth for Columbus and other medium MSA," is captioned " Housing affordability changes across urban-rural and income spectrums show affordability worsening most in the lower-income urban center of Columbus." The y-axis says “Five-year average growth,” and the x-axis says “Metropolitan area size”. The figure presents three sets of bar charts, each representing different urban categories: Columbus, Ohio, other Metropolitan Statistical Areas (MSAs) in Ohio, and MSAs with 1 to 5 million inhabitants; from left to right respectively. The three sets include two shaded bars for above and below median income ZIP codes for four geography types: urban cores, urban areas, suburbs, and exurbs/rural areas. The pairs of bars for each set are colored as follows, from left to right: dense urban cores (blue), urban areas (orange), suburbs (green), and exurbs/rural areas (purple). The dark shaded bar in each pair depicts above median income ZIP codes for that MSA group’s geography type, and the lightly shaded one below median income ZIP codes. Each set of bars shows the 5-year mean ZIP codes level Zillow home price growth with a normal shaded bar, and behind it, the ZIP codes level 5-year mean growth of age-adjusted median incomes for 25-44-year-olds is depicted in a feint bar of the same color. The feint bars for age-adjusted median incomes, are caped by a solid black line for the below median income ZIP codes, and dashed black line for the above median income ZIP codes. Urban areas, suburbs, and exurbs/rural areas classifications are made using National Center for Education Statistics (NCES) locale definitions, while dense urban cores are defined as ZIP codes in the top decile of population density.
For Columbus, the 5-year average growth rates for below their median income urban cores, urban areas, suburbs, and exurbs/rural areas are as follows: home prices grew by 71.6%, 68.9%, 51.7%, and 52.6%, respectively, while incomes grew by 39.6%, 42.5%, 41.2%, and 35.4%, respectively.
For Columbus, the 5-year average growth rates for above their median income urban cores, urban areas, suburbs, and exurbs/rural areas are as follows: home prices grew by 33.1%, 49.1%, 44.7%, and 52.9%, respectively, while incomes grew by 42.2%, 42.8%, 42.6%, and 36.7%, respectively.
For other Ohio MSAs, the 5-year average growth rates for below their median income urban cores, urban areas, suburbs, and exurbs/rural areas are as follows: home prices grew by 64.8%, 60.4%%, 58.6%, and 53.1%, respectively, while incomes grew by 41.9%, 44.7%, 39.1%, and 36.1%, respectively.
For other Ohio MSAs, the 5-year average growth rates for above their median income urban cores, urban areas, suburbs, and exurbs/rural areas are as follows: home prices grew by 49.9%, 50.7%, 47.4%, and 47.4%, respectively, while incomes grew by 43.4%, 41.4%, 37.6%, and 36.4%, respectively.
For MSAs with 1 to 5 million inhabitants, the 5-year average growth rates for below their median income urban cores, urban areas, suburbs, and exurbs/rural areas are as follows: home prices grew by 45.0%, 47.2%, 49.2%, and 48.4%, respectively, while incomes grew by 42.6%, 40.5%, 39.3%, and 37.9%, respectively.
For MSAs with 1 to 5 million inhabitants, the 5-year average growth rates for above their median income urban cores, urban areas, suburbs, and exurbs/rural areas are as follows: home prices grew by 34.6%, 42.5%, 46.5%, and 47.1%, respectively, while incomes grew by 41.3%, 39.4%, 39.4%, and 37.8%, respectively.